Investigation: Wuxing and the Five Planets — Dark Ages Observational Record
Summary
Claim: Wuxing (五行, "Five Phases" / "Five Elements") was developed during the Dark Ages as a direct result of the visible, nonlinear configuration of five bodies: Earth, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, and Mercury — circling and balancing each other in the sky. The five classical elements (water, fire, earth, metal, wood) were not speculative philosophy but observed correspondences: each planet displayed a dominant element and causal interactions between planets were visible. Wuxing is therefore the history of planetary configurations between the Golden Age and the current age — a time when "all science was visible in the sky" and could not be suppressed.
Status: Open. This investigation documents the thesis and traces mainstream vs. alternative chronologies and sources for Wuxing's origin and planetary associations.
1. The Thesis
-
When: Towards the end of the Dark Ages (timeline: 3147–670 BCE); the period when Earth, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, and Mercury were still in close, nonlinear interaction before solar system stabilization (~684 BCE).
-
What was seen: Five planets visibly circling and balancing each other; various forms of interaction (electrical, plasma, tidal) between them; each planet associated with a dominant element:
- Mercury — Metal (central element)
- Mars — Fire (central), also metal
- Venus — Water (most liquid / fluid appearance; not "made of water" but classified as water)
- Jupiter — Wood (interpreted here as electricity / growth / lightning)
- Earth — Earth
-
Implication: The five elements were not speculative. Their causality was acknowledged because it was observed. Wuxing is not a philosophy, religion, or martial art in origin — it is the observational record of that configuration and its cycles (generating, controlling, etc.).
-
Combination, not pure elements: The planets were regarded as the elements themselves — each planet a combination of all elements with one element as the head. Wuxing does not assert what "pure" fire or water do; it asserts that these planets did things, and that interactions between planets gave clues about the lower elements. See also: Suppression of Wuxing (modern-era article).
2. Context: Chaos, Meteorology, and the Gods
- Chaos and meteorology: The Dark Ages were a time of extreme meteorological and electromagnetic chaos — interplanetary lightning, plasma discharges, year-length changes, and repeated "saviour" planets (Jupiter → Venus → Mars) each both liberator and destroyer.
- Respect for all gods: No human could know which god would next "show up" to strike them down or intervene. The one who had departed (Saturn, then Jupiter, then Venus in turn) remained in memory and ritual. Wuxing, in this reading, encodes which bodies were in the sky and how they acted on each other — a survival map as much as a cosmology.
3. Mainstream vs. Timeline Chronology
- Mainstream: Wuxing is usually dated to the Warring States period (5th–3rd c. BCE) and later, with roots in earlier yin–yang and naturalist thought. Planetary associations (e.g. five planets in Chinese astronomy) are often treated as later systematization.
- Timeline thesis: If the Dark Ages ended ~670 BCE and the "five planets" configuration was visible for centuries before that, Wuxing could have crystallized from earlier observational tradition — later formalized and philosophized — with the Warring States texts preserving and reworking that record. Phantom Time / chronology compression could also shift when "Warring States" actually fell.
4. Open Questions
- Textual: Earliest explicit Wuxing–planet links in Chinese sources; any pre–Warring States references to "five phases" and sky events.
- Cross-cultural: Parallels to other "five element" or five-body systems (e.g. Indian, Greek) and whether they point to a shared observational epoch.
- Physical: Consistency of "Mercury = metal, Mars = fire, Venus = water, Jupiter = wood, Earth = earth" with plasma/catastrophist interpretations of each body's appearance and behaviour during the Dark Ages.
5. Related Timeline Articles